This section is showing information that is up to date as of the end of the 2025-26 NCAA Basketball season. To join our email list and get notified when we launch the 2026-27 NCAA Basketball section, register for a free account.

St John's at Butler: Head to Head

Tuesday Jan 6, 2026 7:00 pm - Indianapolis, IN
Odds: St. John's by 4.5, Total Points: 162.5

Matchup Menu: SJU @ BUT

More Games From Jan 6, 2026

Head To Head (Since 1997 Season)

These teams have met 7 times in the last 3 seasons (with 2025-2026 counting as one of those three). St John's has the better record at 7-0.

Below is their head-to-head history back through the 1997 season, not just over the past three seasons.

Date	Winner	Winner H/A/N	Score	ATS Cover	O/U Result
01/28/26	St John's	Home	92-70	St John's -12.5	Over 158.5
01/06/26	St John's	Away	84-70	St John's -4.5	Under 162.5
03/13/25	St John's	Neutral	78-57	St John's -12.0	Under 145.5
02/26/25	St John's	Away	76-70	Push	Under 152.0
01/04/25	St John's	Home	70-62	Butler +11.5	Under 148.0
02/28/24	St John's	Away	82-59	St John's Pk	Under 151.0
01/02/24	St John's	Home	86-70	St John's -6.5	Over 152.5
03/08/23	St John's	Neutral	76-63	St John's -7.0	Under 142.5
02/07/23	Butler	Home	68-66	Butler -1.5	Under 144.5
01/10/23	St John's	Home	77-61	St John's -3.5	Under 149.0
02/18/22	St John's	Home	91-57	St John's -7.5	Over 141.5
02/05/22	St John's	Away	75-72	St John's -2.0	Over 140.5
02/09/21	Butler	Home	76-73	Butler -1.0	Over 138.0
01/12/21	St John's	Home	69-57	St John's -1.5	Under 142.5
03/04/20	Butler	Home	77-55	Butler -9.0	Under 138.0
12/31/19	Butler	Away	60-58	St John's +4.0	Under 135.5
02/12/19	St John's	Home	77-73	Push	Over 146.0
01/19/19	Butler	Home	80-71	Butler -4.5	Over 150.0
02/28/18	St John's	Home	75-68	St John's +2.5	Under 145.5
01/27/18	Butler	Home	70-45	Butler -7.5	Under 146.0
02/15/17	Butler	Home	110-86	Butler -10.5	Over 151.0
12/29/16	St John's	Home	76-73	St John's +8.5	Over 148.5
02/06/16	Butler	Away	89-56	Butler -11.0	Under 148.5
01/16/16	Butler	Home	78-58	Butler -19.5	Under 147.5
02/03/15	Butler	Home	85-62	Butler -6.0	Over 131.5
01/03/15	Butler	Away	73-69	Butler +3.5	Over 122.0
02/18/14	St John's	Home	77-52	St John's -9.0	Under 130.0
01/25/14	St John's	Away	69-52	St John's +3.5	Under 133.5